Archive for April, 2009

Google meets the mob

Friday, April 3rd, 2009 by Jon Clements

UPDATE #2: This is what Rory Cellan-Jones found in belligerent Buckinghamshire and this is what he says.

UPDATE: Hear what Google has to say about it.

 As I write, BBC technology correspondent, Rory Cellan-Jones is on his way to the Buckinghamshire village of Broughton, where the locals are revolting.

Is this a copy-cat outbreak of #G20 summit protests? Actually, no; it’s all about the Web’s favourite search engine Google.  

According to news sources, local residents have sent the Google Street View vehicle packing by forming a human barricade. Thames Valley Police, in customary non-judgemental police speak, report a “dispute between a crowd of people and a Google Street View contractor”. It’s about privacy, say Broughton’s inhabitants; Google says it’s working within the law and that there’s “an easy way to request removal of imagery”.

What’s got Broughton so hot under the collar? According to UpMyStreet the inhabitants have a bigger predilection for “golf, gardening and visiting National Trust properties” - hardly the stuff of anarchic, direct action.

But while Google sees Street View as a “rich, immersive browsing experience”, some Broughton people see it as a burglars’ charter.

Just this week, while talking with a client about the impact of social media, the question was mooted: “Has Google gone too far with Street View?” But despite the privacy backlash on its launch, there was no suggestion it would result in Home Counties’ insurrection.

Twittering lawyer, John Halton, pictures a baying medieval mob, though is careful to disclaim this view:

 broughton.png

Others in the Twitterverse are divided on the topic, but have the “good people of Broughton” touched a nerve within the populace that Google - maybe over-estimating the benign acceptance it enjoys around the world - never anticipated?  

Broughton seems to be saying: “Listen Google, I’m happy for you to track down the cheapest car insurance and my secondary school sweetheart, but keep your 360 degree cyber nose out of my property.” An Englishman’s home remains his castle, it seems. You don’t get much more medieval than that.

G20 and the protest positioning

Wednesday, April 1st, 2009 by Jon Clements

g20.png

UPDATE #2: The BBC’s Rory Cellan-Jones blogs his thoughts on the use of social networks - or not - at the G20 protests.

UPDATE: Guardian Online photogallery captures the drama of today’s #G20 protests in London. 

The G20 summit kicks off (so to speak) in London today and Sky News has reporters using that latest craze, Twitter - the future of Guardian newspaper publishing, ho ho  - to send dispatches from the front line.

Apart from the frisson caused by French president, Nicolas Sarkozy, threatening - as the Mirror puts it - to “flounce” out of the summit if he doesn’t see tougher banking regulation, what have other protestors got lined up for the summit, and how will it sit with the armchair public not pitching tents or painting their faces in London today?

The G20 Meltdown group, whose leaders are described with lurid delight by the Daily Telegraph has positioned itself in a way reminiscent of the Poll Tax protest in 1990, with the call of “Can’t Pay, Won’t Pay” and “We’re taking to the streets”.The Poll Tax demo marked one of the most violent public demonstrations the capital had seen “for a century”, but the action undoubtedly hastened the demise of Margaret Thatcher as Prime Minister and the abolition of the tax itself.

But will effigies of the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse, calls for “a very English revolution” in the spirit of 1649 and the “overthrow of capitalism” have a resonance today? As angry as people may be with bankers and politicians right now, do they want to hand over the reigns of power to an organisation which is trying, somehow, to combine the ethics of love and lynch mob?

The Campaign Against Climate Change is opting for the more quietly symbolic, marking “Fossil Fools Day” with a giant block of ice representing the melting polar ice caps while Stop the War Coalition is rallying tomorrow with protestors bringing “shoes, baby dolls, photos and other symbols of death and destruction”.

It’s a hearts and minds battle from both the politicians’ and protestors’ sides of the ramparts - but is the British public ready for revolution? 

Follow the Twitterverse’s on the ground take on the #G20.